Who is the Greatest WAC Football Player of Of All Time?

Who is the Greatest WAC Football Player of Of All Time?

Bookmark and Share

Who is the Greatest WAC Football Player of Of All Time?
Back in 1962, the first ever season of Western Athletic Conference football was played. Over the years the WAC has been blessed with Hall of Fame players, record breakers and even a Heisman Trophy winner. In celebration of the 60th anniversary of WAC Football, we want you to choose the Greatest Player of All Time (GOAT)! We have broken the voting into four eras (1960's/70s, 1980s, 1990s and 2000s). A blue ribbon panel ranked players 1-8 in each era. Now you get to decide who is the best. Vote on our Twitter and Instagram pages July 11-15 to decide the #WACfbGOAT! 
 1960s and 1970s
  
Mike Haynes, 
Arizona State
Position: Defensive Back
Years in WAC: 1972-75
Seed: 1
     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (1997)
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2000)
  • 2-Time All-American
  • 15-Year WAC Anniversary First Team
  • 1973 All-WAC First Team
  • 1974 All-WAC First Team
  • 1975 All-WAC First Team
  • NFL 75th Anniversary Team
  • NFL 100th Anniversary Team
  • 9 x Pro Bowl
  • NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year
  • Super Bowl Champion
  • 1976 NFL First Round Pick (5th overall – New England)
  
Curley Culp, Arizona State
Position: Nose Guard
Years in WAC: 1965-68
Seed: 2
     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (2013)
  • 15-Year WAC Anniversary First Team
  • 1967 WAC Lineman of the Year
  • 1966 All-WAC First Team
  • 1967 All-WAC First Team
  • NCAA Heavyweight Wrestling Champion (1967)
  • 3-Time WAC Wrestling Champion
  • 13 Seasons in NFL
  • NFL Defensive Player of the Year (1975)
  • 6-Time Pro Bowl
  • Super Bowl Champion
  • 1968 NFL/AFL Second Round Pick (Denver)


Marc Wilson, BYU
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1976-79
Seed: 3

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (1996)
  • 1979 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1979 First Team All-American
  • 1977 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1979 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • WAC All-Time 25th in Passing Yards (7,636)
  • WAC All-Time 19th in TD Passes (61)
  • #6 Retired by BYU
  • 10 Seasons in NFL
  • 2-Time Super Bowl Champion
  • 1980 NFL First Round Pick (15th overall – Oakland)


John Jefferson,
Arizona State
Position: Wide Receiver
Years in WAC: 1974-77
Seed: 4

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2002)
  • 1977 First Team All-American
  • WAC All-Time 28th in Receiving Yards (2,824)
  • 7 Seasons in NFL
  • 4 x Pro Bowl
  • 2 x First Team All-NFL
  • Led NFL in Receiving Yards (1980)
  • Led NFL in TD catches (1978, 80)
  • 1978 NFL First Round Pick (14th overall – San Diego)

 


J.D. Hill,
Arizona State
Position: Wide Receiver
Years in WAC: 1967-70
Seed: 5

     
  • 15-Year WAC Anniversary First Team
  • 1970 All-WAC First Team
  • MVP of Senior Bowl
  • Also Played Baseball and Ran Track at ASU
  • 7 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x Pro Bowl
  • 1971 NFL First Round Pick (4th overall – Buffalo)

Danny White,
Arizona State
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1971-73
Seed: 6

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (1998)
  • 15-Year WAC Anniversary First Team
  • 1973 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1973 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 21st in TD Passes (59)
  • #11 Retired by Arizona State
  • 12 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x Pro Bowl
  • 1974 NFL First Third Round Pick (Dallas)
  • Last player to start as punter and QB


Mike Bell,
Colorado State
Position: Defensive Line
Years in WAC: 1975-78
Seed: 7

     
  • 1978 First Team All-American
  • 1977 WAC Lineman of the Year
  • 1977 All-WAC First Team
  • 1978 All-WAC First Team
  • 12 Seasons in NFL
  • 2-Time Pro Bowl Alternate
  • 1979 NFL First Round Pick (2nd overall – Kansas City)


Jim Kiick,
Wyoming
Position: Running Back
Years in WAC: 1965-67
Seed: 8

     
  • 15-Year WAC Anniversary First Team
  • 1966 All-WAC First Team
  • 1967 All-WAC First Team
  • 1968 All-WAC First Team
  • First player to be First Team All-WAC 3 times
  • Sun Bowl MVP
  • 7 Seasons in NFL
  • Member of undefeated Super Bowl Champion Miami Dolphins
  • 2 x AFL All-Star
  • 1968 NFL Fifth Round Pick (Miami)
 1980s
 
Steve Young,
BYU
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1981-83
Seed: 1
     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (2005)College Football Hall of Fame (2001)
  • 1983 Runner-Up Heisman Trophy
  • 1983 Davey O’Brien Award (Best QB in NCAA)
  • 1983 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1983 First Team All-American
  • 1982 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1983 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1982 First Team All-WAC
  • 1983 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 22nd in Passing Yards (7,737)
  • WAC All-Time 24th in TD Passes (56)
  • #8 Retired by BYU
  • 14 Seasons in NFL
  • 2 x NFL MVP (1992, 94)
  • 7 x Pro Bowl
  • 3 x First Team All-Pro
  • 4 x NFL Passing TD Leader
  • 6 x NFL Passer Rating Leader
  • 5 x NFL Completion Percentage Leader
  • 3 x Super Bowl Champion
 
Jim McMahon,
BYU
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1977-81
Seed: 2
     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (1998)
  • 1981 Davey O’Brien Award (Best QB in NCAA)
  • 1981 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1981 First Team All-American
  • 1978 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1980 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1981 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1978 All-WAC First Team
  • 1980 All-WAC First Team
  • 1981 All-WAC First Team
  • WAC All-Time 13th in passing yards (9,563)
  • WAC All-Time 6th in TD Passes (84)
  • #9 Retired by BYU
  • 14 Seasons in NFL
  • NFL Comeback Player of the Year (1991)
  • 1 x Pro Bowl
  • 2 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1982 NFL First Round Pick – 5th overall (Chicago)

 
Jay Novacek,
Wyoming
Position: Tight End
Years in WAC: 1982-84
Seed: 3

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2008)
  • 1984 First Team All-American
  • 1984 First Team All-WAC
  • Set NCAA single-season record for average per reception (22.6 yards) by a tight end
  • 1984 WAC Decathlon Champion
  • 1984 NCAA Decathlon All-American (4th)
  • Competed in 1984 Olympic Trials in Decathlon
  • 10 Seasons in NFL
  • 5 x Pro Bowl
  • 3 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1 x First Team All-Pro
  • 1985 NFL Sixth Round Pick (St. Louis)
 

 
Chad Hennings,
Air Force
Position: Defensive Line
Years in WAC: 1984-87
Seed: 4

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2006)
  • NCAA Silver Anniversary Award
  • 1987 Outland Trophy (Best Interior Lineman in NCAA)
  • 1987 First Team All-American
  • 1987 WAC Defensive Player of the Year
  • 1988 Stan Bates Award
  • 1987 First Team All-WAC
  • Japan Bowl MVP (1988)
  • Became A-10 Pilot
  • Deployed twice to Iraq during Gulf War
  • Twice Awarded the Air Force Acheivement Medal
  • 8 Seasons in NFL
  • 3 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1988 NFL Eleventh Round Pick (Dallas)



Jason Buck,
BYU
Position: Defensive Line
Years in WAC: 1983-87
Seed: 5

     
  • 1986 Outland Trophy (Best Interior Lineman in NCAA)
  • 1985 WAC Defensive Player of the Year
  • 1985 First Team All-WAC
  • 1986 First Team All-WAC
  • Member of 1984 BYU National Champion Team
  • 5 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1987 NFL First Round Pick – 17th overall (Cincinnati)

Terance Mathis,
New Mexico
Position: Wide Receiver
Years in WAC: 1985-89
Seed: 6 

     
  • 1989 First Team All-American
  • 1986 First Team All-WAC
  • 1987 First Team All-WAC
  • 1989 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 4th in Receiving Yards (4,254)
  • WAC All-Time 5th in Receiving TDs (36)
  • 12 Seasons in NFL
  • Atlanta Falcons Man of the Year (1998)
  • 1990 NFL Sixth Round Pick  (Miami)
 


Robbie Bosco,
BYU
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1983-85
Seed: 7 

     
  • 1984 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1984 Third in Heisman Trophy voting
  • 1984 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1984 First Team All-WAC
  • 1985 Second Team All-WAC
  • QB of 1984 BYU National Champion Team
  • #6 Retired by BYU
  • WAC All-Time 17th in Passing Yards (8,418)
  • WAC All-Time 16th in TD Passes (66)
  • 2 Seasons in NFL
  • 1986 NFL Third Round Pick (Green Bay)


Steve Bartalo,
Colorado State
Position: 
Running Back
Years in WAC: 
1983-86
Seed: 8

     
  • 1987 Stan Bates Award
  • 1986 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1983 WAC Newcomer of the Year
  • 1984 First Team All-WAC
  • 1985 First Team All-WAC
  • 1986 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 2nd in rushing yards (4,813)
  • WAC All-Time 5th in Rushing TDs (46)
  • WAC All-Time 21st in Points Scored (294)
  • 2 Seasons in NFL
  • 1987 NFL Sixth Round Pick (Tampa Bay)
 1990s
Marshall Faulk,
San Diego State
Position: 
Running Back
Years in WAC: 
1991-93
Seed:
1
     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (2011)
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2017)
  • 1992, 93 First Team All-American
  • 1992, 93 First Team All-American
  • Heisman Trophy Runner Up (1992)
  • Heisman Trophy 4th Place (1993)
  • 1993 Joe Kearney Award
  • 1994 Joe Kearney Award
  • 1992 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1991 First Team All-WAC
  • 1992 First Team All-WAC
  • 1993 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 3rd in Rushing Yards (4,569)
  • WAC All-Time 3nd in rushing TDs (57)
  • WAC All-Time 3rd in Points Scored (376)
  • 13 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x NFL MVP (2000)
  • 3 x NFL Offensive Player of the Year (1999, 2000, 2001)
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year
  • 3 x First Team All-Pro
  • 7 x Pro Bowl
  • 1994 NFL First Round Pick – Second Overall (Indianapolis)

 

Ty Detmer,
BYU
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC: 
1988-91
Seed:
2

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2012)
  • 1990 Heisman Trophy Winner
  • 1990 Maxwell Award (Best Player in NCAA)
  • 1990 Davey O’Brien Award (Best QB in NCAA)
  • 1991 Davey O’Brien Award (Best QB in NCAA)
  • 1990 First Team All-American
  • 1991 First Team All-American
  • 1990 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1991 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1989 First Team All-WAC
  • 1990 First Team All-WAC
  • 1991 First Team All-WAC
  • #14 Retired by BYU
  • WAC All-Time 2nd in Passing Yards (15,031)
  • WAC All-Time 2nd in TD Passes (121)
  • 14 Seasons in NFL
  • 1992 NFL Ninth Round Pick (Green Bay)
         

Trent Dilfer,
Fresno State
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC: 
1991-93
Seed:
3
     
  • 1993 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1993 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1992 First Team All-WAC
  • 1993 First Team All-WAC
  • 1992 Led NCAA in Passing Efficiency
  • Set NCAA record for consecutive attempts no INTs (271)
  • 30th in TD passes (51)
  • 14 seasons in NFL
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1 x Pro Bowl
  • 1993 NFL First Round Pick – 6th Overall (Tampa Bay)
  • Left after junior season for NFL Draft

Marcus Harris,
Wyoming
Position: Wide Receiver
Years in WAC: 1993-96
Seed: 4

     
  • 1996 Biletnikoff Award (Best WR in NCAA)
  • 1996 First Team All-American
  • 1996 WAC Pacific Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1994 First Team All-WAC
  • 1995 First Team All-WAC
  • 1996 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time Leader in Receiving Yards (4,518)
  • WAC All-Time 4th in Receiving TDs (38)
  • 1996 NFL Seventh Round Pick (Detroit)
 

Ryan Yarborough,
Wyoming
Position: Wide Receiver
Years in WAC: 1990-93
Seed: 5

     
  • 1992 First Team All-WAC
  • 1993 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 2nd in Receiving Yards (4,357)
  • WAC All-Time Leader in Receiving TDs (42)
  • WAC All-TIme 26th in Points Scored (256)
  • Set NCAA record for games with TD reception (27)
  • 4 seasons in NFL
  • 1994 NFL Second Round Pick (NY Jets)
 

Greg Myers,
Colorado State
Position: Defensive Back
Years in WAC: 1992-95
Seed: 6

     
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2012)
  • 1995 Jim Thorpe Award (Best DB in NCAA)
  • 1995 First Team All-American
  • 1995 Honda National Scholar-Athlete of the Year
  • 1996 Stan Bates Award
  • 1992 First Team All-WAC
  • 1993 First Team All-WAC
  • 1994 First Team All-WAC
  • 1995 First Team All-WAC
  • Helped CSU to WAC titles in 1994, 95
  • 5 seasons in NFL
  • 1996 NFL Fifth Round Pick (Cincinnati)
  • Now an anesthesiologist in Denver


Steve Sarkisian,
BYU
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC: 
1995-96
Seed:
 7

     
  • 1996 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 1996 WAC Mountain Offensive Player of the Year
  • 1996 First Team All-WAC Mountain Division
  • WAC All-Time 28th in Passing Yards (7,464)
  • WAC All-Time 28th in TD Passes (53)
  • Head Coach at Washington (2009-13) USC (2014-15) and now at Texas (2021-present)


Brian Urlacher,
New Mexico
Position: Defensive Back
Years in WAC: 1996-98
Seed: 8

     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (2018)
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2017)
  • 1998 First Team All-WAC Pacific Division
  • Also returned kicks and punts
  • #44 Retired by UNM
  • 13 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x NFL Defensive Player of the Year (2005)
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year
  • 4 x First Team All-Pro
  • 8 x Pro Bowl
  • 2000 NFL First Round Pick – 9th overall (Chicago)
 
 2000s

LaDainian Tomlinson,
TCU
Position: Running Back
Years in WAC: 1997-00
Seed: 1

     
  • Pro Football Hall of Fame (2017)
  • College Football Hall of Fame (2014)
  • 2000 Doak Walker Award (Best RB in NCAA)
  • 2000 All-American
  • 4th in Heisman Trophy (2000)
  • 2001 Joe Kearney Award
  • 1999 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2000 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • WAC All-Time Leader in Rushing Yards (5,263)
  • WAC All-Time 4th in rushing TDs (56)
  • WAC All-Time 12th in Points Scored (324)
  • #5 Retired by TCU
  • 10 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x NFL MVP (2006)
  • 1 x NFL Offensive Player of the Year (2006)
  • 1 x Walter Payton Man of the Year (2006)
  • NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year
  • 3 x First Team All-Pro
  • 5 x Pro Bowl
  • 2001 NFL First Round Pick – Fifth Overall (San Diego)

David Carr,
Fresno State
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 1997-01
Seed: 2

     
  • 2001 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 2001 Johnny Unitas Award (Best Senior QB in NCAA)
  • 5th in Heisman Trophy (2001)
  • 2002 Joe Kearney Award
  • 2001 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • WAC All-Time 19th in TD Passes (61)
  • 2001 First Team All-WAC
  • 2000 Second Team All-WAC
  • #8 Retired by Fresno State
  • 11 Seasons in NFL
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 1 x NFL Completion Percentage Leader
  • NFL All-Rookie Team
  • 2002 NFL First Round Pick – 1st overall (Houston)
 

Colt Brennan,
Hawai'i
Position: Quarterback
Years in WAC: 2005-07
Seed: 3

     
  • 2006 Sammy Baugh Trophy (Top Passer in NCAA)
  • 6th in Heisman Trophy (2006)
  • 3rd in Heisman Trophy (2007)
  • 2007 Joe Kearney Award
  • 2006 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2007 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2006 First Team All-WAC
  • 2007 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time Leader in TD Passes (131)
  • WAC All-Time 3rd in Passing Yards (14,193)
  • 3 seasons in NFL
  • 2008 NFL Sixth Round Pick (Washington)
 

Colin Kaepernick,
Nevada
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC:
2007-10
Seed:
 4

     
  • 8th in Heisman Trophy (2010)
  • 2011 Joe Kearney Award
  • 2008 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2010 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2008 First Team All-WAC
  • 2010 First Team All-WAC
  • 2009 Second Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 6th in Rushing Yards (4,112)
  • WAC All-Time 1st in Rushing TDs (59)
  • WAC All-Time 10th in Passing Yards (10,098)
  • WAC All-Time 8th in TD Passes (82)
  • WAC All-Time 6th in Points Scored (362)
  • Only player in NCAA history with 10,000 passing and 4,000 rushing yards
  • Graduated with 4.0 GPA
  • 6 seasons in NFL
  • NFL Record QB rushing yards in one game (181)
  • 2011 NFL Second Round Pick (San Francisco)

 

 

Kellen Moore,
Boise State
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC:
2008-10
Seed:
 5

     
  • 2009 First Team All-American
  • 7th in Heisman Trophy (2009)
  • 2010 Joe Kearney Award
  • 2009, 10 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2009, 10 WAC Offensive Player of the Year
  • 2009, 10 First Team All-WAC
  • 2009, 10 First Team All-WAC
  • 2008 Second Team All-WAC
  • 6th in Passing Yards (10,867)
  • 4th in TD Passes (99)
  • 5 seasons in NFL
  • Now Dallas Cowboys OC
 

Timmy Chang,
Hawai'i
Position: 
Quarterback
Years in WAC:
2000-04
Seed:
 6

     
  • 2004 First Team All-WAC
  • 2002 Second Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time Leader in Passing Yards (17,072)
  • 3rd in TD Passes (117)
  • 2nd in NCAA history in Passing Yards
  • 2 seasons in NFL
  • Head Coach at Hawai’i
 

Bobby Wagner,
Utah State
Position:
Linebacker
Years in WAC:
2008-11
Seed:
 7

       
  • 2009 First Team All-WAC
  • 2010 First Team All-WAC
  • 2011 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time Leader in Tackles (446)
  • Senior Bowl MVP (2012)
  • 10 Seasons in NFL (still in NFL)
  • 1 x Super Bowl Champion
  • 6 x First Team All-Pro
  • 8 x Pro Bowl
  • 2 x NFL Leader in Tackles
  • 2012 NFL Second Round Pick (Seattle)

Davone Bess,
Hawai'i
Position:
Wide Receiver
Years in WAC:
2005-07
Seed:
 8

     
  • 2005 First Team All-WAC
  • 2006 First Team All-WAC
  • 2007 First Team All-WAC
  • WAC All-Time 3rd in Receiving Yards (4,345)
  • WAC All-Time Leader in receptions (293)
  • WAC All-Time 6th in Receiving Yards (3,610)
  • WAC All-Time 2nd in Receiving TDs (41)
  • 5 Seasons in NFL